Wage Up! Way too common open enrollment mistakes

Insurance is a complicated topic, full of details, loopholes and fine print that can come back to bite even the most savvy consumer. That's why open enrollment can be a stressful time for so many people.

While it may be impossible to avoid every little snag and pitfall that comes with trying to pick the right healthcare plan, you can at least steer clear of the most common mistakes. Here are some blunders people tend to make at open enrollment, from someone who's made more than a few.

Not considering an HSA-eligible HDHP

A few months ago, my husband and I moved from Colorado to Indiana. We're self-employed, so we buy our health insurance through the Healthcare Marketplace. After arriving in Indiana, we had to purchase insurance again in our new state.

While looking through the various healthcare options, I found myself stuck between two similar-looking plans. One had the words "HSA" in its name, the other didn't. They were both high-deductible plans, so I assumed both were HSA-eligible.

I finally decided on the plan without "HSA" in the name and started the signup process. I got embarrassingly far into the process before I realized what should have been obvious - the "HSA" designation was meant to highlight whether or not a plan was eligible for use with an HSA. The plan I was signing up for wasn't.

Not every high-deductible insurance plan allows users to open HSAs. The plan must have a deductible of at least $1,350 for individuals and $2,700 for families. The out-of-pocket max must be no more than $6,650 for individuals and $13,300 for families.

If signing up for an HSA-eligible plan is important to you, learn from my almost-mistake and verify that your HDHP qualifies.

Choosing services you don't need

All of us want good healthcare. We want to know that if something happens, we'll be taken care of. Sometimes that attitude leads us to sign up for more healthcare than we actually need.

If you've always purchased a gold-level plan and are in good health, consider dialing it back this year and going with a high-deductible plan. Not only will you save on your monthly premiums, you'll also get the benefit of contributing to a tax-deductible HSA. This decision could save you thousands of dollars in just one year.

Choosing an FSA-eligible plan, but contributing the wrong amount

Still not sure about moving to an HDHP but want tax-free benefits? Maybe a more traditional healthcare plan with an FSA is better for your upcoming year. But even if you consider yourself a flex spending guru, some FSA veterans still struggle to predict the right amount to contribute.

FSAs require you to choose your contribution amount during open enrollment. The amount will be taken out of your paycheck and deposited directly to your FSA. You can only change your FSA contribution amount if you have a qualifying event like marriage, divorce, change in employment status or having a child.

It doesn't matter if you funded your FSA because you were planning an expensive procedure that subsequently gets cancelled. With limited exceptions, FSA funds may be subject to "use it or lose it", meaning you'll need to spend your full election or risk losing your hard-earned dollars (good thing we have thousands of FSA-eligible items for you to use your remaining funds on).

That's why it's always important to accurately estimate how much you might spend on healthcare expenses before signing up for an FSA.

Whether you're spending steadily or saving for something, Wage Up! is where we highlight the latest services available to buy with your HSA, every Monday on the HSA Learning Center. And for everything else about your health and financial wellness, be sure to follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

HSA updates, stories and deals, right in your inbox!